Dumbledore Really is Dead
(This will probably not make sense unless you have read the Harry Potter series, and if you haven't read the 6th book and don't like spoilers, don't read this.)
After reading Harry Potter 6, there has been a lot of controversy on whether or not Dumbledore was really dead. At first I was thinking, "Duh, didn't any of you read the book?" But then I remembered how mad people were after they read the 5th book, and how they still thought Sirius would come back. These two examples remind me of Elvis, because when he died, people believed he really was not, and people even started to say he was an alien. People just cannot seem to come to reality when someone they like leaves. Maybe its some sort of defence mechanism, like denial, or they're just stupid. (sorry) So since I believe Dumbledore is dead, and everyone else says he is alive, I have decided to, at least try, to prove my point.
Yes I know this is all silly, and that Harry Potter is fictitious, (No wait, he's British.) but I wanted to write about something I feel very strongly about.
The problem with these Harry Potter fans is that they have no proof that Dumbledore is dead. Mostly what I hear and read is, "He just can't be dead. It's not fair." or "He was faking his death." But why? There is no point in why Dumbledore should fake his own death and go in hiding. He is certainly not helping anybody by 'pretending' to be dead.
I even read a very hilarious remark from one of them: "He'll probably pull a Gandalf in book 7." I mean, come on, who do they think J.K. Rowling is? She is a very talented writer, and she is not going to steal other people's ideas from stories. There is a reason Dumbledore died - so that Harry would finally have to fight Lord Voldemort alone. If "The Only Wizard he Ever Feared" was in the way of their battle, the book would be zero fun. Mostly readers like books when the advantage is in the bad guy's favor, and the hero has to overcome their power, but with Dumbledore there, Harry would just be sitting on the side, watching Dumbledore kick Voldemort's butt. Now, wouldn't that be fun?
While I was researching this topic I came upon this website, and they had some pretty good proof that he was still alive. I was even compelled to believe them, but decided it would be much more fun to prove them wrong, even if my proof sucks. One of the things they said was that as Snape used the Avada Kedavra spell on Dumbledore, he thought a different spell, and so he did not really die. This, I think is rather absurd. How could that even be possible? These people have to use common sense, Snape said it, so his wand did the magic. It's like telling your computer to do something. It'll do that, not the opposite.
Also, this person said that it could not have been the Avada Kedavra spell because it did not do the same thing it did to the other people. In book 4, for example, Cedric flinches as he is hit by the spell, and he merely slumps over dead. But in book 6, it does something different.
Snape raised his wand and pointed it directly at Dumbledore. "Avada Kedavra!" A jet of green light shot from the end of Snape's wand and hit Dumbledore squarely in the chest. Harry's scream of horror never left him; silently he was forced to watch as Dumbledore was blasted into the air. For a split second, he seemed to hang suspended beneath the shining skull, and then he slowly fell backward, like a great rag doll, over the battlements and out of sight. (HBP pg. 596)
They forgot to point out that Dumbledore did not flinch, like Cedric did, which could be part of the reason that it was different. Dumbledore didn't care if he died, so he had no reason to be afraid and flinch since it was a quick death. The reason I say this is because in page 595, is says,
"Severus..." ...For the first time, Dumbledore was pleading. ..."Severus...please..." and then he is killed. But Dumbledore is not the kind of man to plead for his life. He cares about his students much more, because whenever they were in trouble, he did not go save his life first. He even came to the rescue at the end of book 5 and fought Voldemort.
They said, "It could not have been the Avada Kedavra, because he flew up into the air," but Dumbledore is a much more powerful wizard than Cedric Diggory, or that one dude that was killed at the beginning of book 4, and because of what I said in the paragraph above.
Just one more thing, and then I am done. In the next chapter, we find out Snape is the Half Blood Prince while Harry tries to use Snape's own spells on him. We've always known Snape was rotten, but when Harry tries to jinx him, he puts Harry under extreme pain, and then runs away, without killing him. First of all, he did not kill him because he knows Voldemort needs to kill him, not because Snape is good and loves Harry Potter. You might think that he hurt Harry just because he's a jerk. No. Snape hurt Harry pretty bad, and kept doing it until Buckbeak came and stopped him. It's because Snape is evil and likes hurting people. So that is why I believe he really did mean to kill Dumbledore, and HE DID!
So, I don't know if you think he's alive or dead after reading this, so please post and tell me what you thought. And if you still don't believe me, then just think, Dumbledore was pushing 150 years, his hand was shriveled and black, and he had just taken large amounts of unknown poison. He was going to expire sooner or later.
Ah, I feel better now.
